PL is CC: The Whole Timeline

“PL is CC” is a pretty frequent topic bought up on the wiki. It had basically divided the wiki in two. The theory was that PigLover was secretly ComicsCreatorz But CC and Pl wanted to disprove the theory.

1.1: PL and CC leave
PL and CC had both left the wiki, stating that they were sick of the wiki. They had other reasons for doing so but we are gonna skip those for now. PL had been somewhat disliked by some, but it was nothing compared to what he was about to get.

1.2: BNB suggests a theory
One day, BNB suggested a theory that PigLover and ComicsCreatorz were the same people, and one person could be controlling the account. People basically laughed it off. But, as time went on, more people began to believe the theory. People realized there could be some truth to it.

1.3: PET IP checks
PET asked fandom for an IP check between the users. After a bit of a wait, PL and CC were revealed to have the same IP.

2.1: PL gets hated… a lot
After this, people got very, very mad. Many people were saying that they had lost respect for PL, and that they were mad at him. Many people did things such as create posts, pages, and more. Almost everyone on the wiki disliked PL.

2.2: People start to get tired of the topic
As time went on, people started to get bored of the PL topic. People were starting to just accept it and move on at this point.

But, there were some users that were still bringing it up. Mainly PET, but also somewhat Henry and Yoda. This prompted ComicRater to make a post.

2.3: “Forget about PL”
After being annoyed by this, ComicRater made a post, called “Forget about PL.” This was basically a post saying to stop bringing up PL so much because the topic was getting boring and they had already left. The majority of the wiki had agreed with this, except PET mainly.

2.4: PET vs ComicRater + ZachOWott
One time, PET made a response to what Henry said about PL.

This caused Zach and ComicRater to make long posts to forget about the topic and that he should stop. A lot of this could have been from past annoyances, such as PET making 4 blogs about the situation.

There was a big argument on the article where they wrong rebuttals to each other's points.

PET then made a video on the subject, which he deleted after a lecture from CR.

The argument eventually got carried over to discord, basically 2 hours of arguing about the situation.

After some time, CR and PET apologized to each other. But, this sparked a long dislike between PET and Zach.

3.1: Swasimcool gets a hold of PL
4 months later, something crazy happened. Swasimcool was trying to get a hold of PL on roblox, and he responded! People went crazy over this and were asking for messages to be delivered. PL friended some people that wanted to talk to.

3.2: Attempt to disprove the claims
When they came back, a huge argument started in the wiki, that basically turned the wiki into two sides: PL is CC, and PL is NOT CC. Pro PL: ComicRater, BNB, PL, CC, Swasimcool, GoldenGlory4life, Salty Byleth Main Anti PL: Henry Hudson, Yoda, Fancy, 7o’clock, ToPhu31, PET, P-Dog, Spyroclub, SuperTalker Neutral: GarfieldMN (who didn’t want to get involved in this)

3.3: The claims and rebuttals
PL isn’t CC claims:

•Both typing very fast on different accounts, one person can’t do this

Rebuttal: PL could have asked a friend to type

•How would a friend play Roblox, know so much about the wiki, answer questions, and VC?

Rebuttal: N/A

•Relating to before, PL and CC have played Roblox at the same time and answered questions about the wiki, one person can’t do this

Rebuttal: He could have asked a friend to play and tell him what to say

•On Roblox, PL and CC had both spent a lot of money on both accounts, why would one person do this? Rebuttal: N/A

•They had the same IP because they are brothers

Rebuttal: They never stated they were brothers before

•PL and CC had made a video of them both drawing (with 3 hands in the video) with both different styles

Rebuttal: one person can draw in different styles, he could have asked a friend to do it

•PL and CC voice chatted with different voices at the same time (Note: This happened way later, but it was still a claim so I’m not gonna exclude it.

Rebuttal: N/A

PL is CC claims:

•They have the same IP address

Rebuttal: They are brothers, so they have the same IP, and/or they made the account on the same computer as each other

•PL had stated that CC hadn’t talked to him for weeks because of the incident, yet they claim they are brothers

Rebuttal: PL said it was a lie to get sympathy

•PL and CC had always been seen agreeing with eachother

Rebuttal: They claimed it was nepotism

•PL had never stated he and CC we’re brothers before

Rebuttal: PL said he didn’t feel like he needed to, so he didn’t do it (If I missed any feel free to tell me)

Some of the “PL is CC” people went on to ask for a voice reveal or face reveal as proof. At the time, they didn’t want to because of privacy.

3.4: The topic dies down… sorta
The theory wasn’t necessarily proven true or false, so it started to die down on the wiki. It was rarely bought up, except by ToPhu31.

3.5: Still bought up on discord
Even after months of the event happening, the topic was still frequently bought up on discord. This likely lead to…

4.1: CC requests a voice chat
One day on discord, CC said he would be willing to voice chat. But, he had rules. He said that it couldn’t be recorded or sent to other users. ComicRater agreed to this, and they hopped into a voice chat. They talked at the same time with different voices. They also answered some questions about the wiki to show they weren’t just grabbing a friend to do it. CC and PL then agreed to show BNB.

4.2: BNB’s post
After chatting with BNB, BNB went on to make a wiki post. He said in the post that it was proof that they were different. The post got generally positive feedback.

4.3: More join the vc
After a little bit, CC and PL went on to invite more people; Some included PDog, Sway, moothu, Henry, pet, and more. They had all gotten into a voice chat with PL. This had caused some PL is CC supporters to change their opinions for the time being. These include Moothu, Henry, Neptune, Moon Man, and possibly more I missed. ToPhu still thought they were the same, and an argument spiked between him and some others.

4.4: Proven…?
This was seen as proof by some users. They said that it’s not likely that they could grab a friend to answer questions about the wiki like that. As for the other PL is CC people,

, Zach: Refused to voice chat.

PDog: Didn’t vc with them yet.

PET: See above.

Spyroclub: See above.

Swasimcool: Was still on the fence.

Yoda: Didn’t vc with them yet.

So, was the theory disproven? To the majority of users, yes, it had been. But, you never know.

Alright, that’s all! Thanks for reading!

Bye!

-CR